Wednesday, October 5, 2016

Pools of Darkness: Some Old Friends

Buddy! It's been too long!
So far, Pools of Darkness has done a great job incorporating characters and themes from the previous games, and the way that it handled Tyranthraxus is just about perfect. It would have been too much if Tyranthraxus had been the "big bad" (again), or even one of Bane's lieutenants. I mean, my characters were able to defeat him at Level 6, so the game would have had to jump through some logical hoops to make him still a threat at Level 30.

Plus, Tyranthraxus is the ultimate example of a petty tyrant. He has this ability to jump between host bodies, which allowed him to take some powerful forms and exert some control over small areas. But he's not very bright, doesn't plan well, and is too influenced by emotion. The least convincing part of his character is in Curse of the Azure Bonds, when he calmly hangs out at the Standing Stones, directing the party to the next mission. It must have been all he could do not to whip off his hood the moment he first saw us, give some idiotic villain's exposition, and attack us with a party of whatever outcasts he was able to find in the forest.
That might make a good subtitle some day!
Thus, when I first encountered his name again in the ruins of Myth Drannor, I inwardly groaned. "This #*$@ again?" I said, at first intending to actually use that as my post subtitle. But it played out perfect.

On the outskirts of Myth Drannor, I ran across Princess Nacacia, whose impulsive elopement started off the story in Curse of the Azure Bonds. She's apparently taken on some responsibility in the intervening years ("weariness mars her once carefree face"), because here she was in charge of a contingent of Knights of Myth Drannor, trying to figure out whether the rakshasa that occupy the ruins are allied with Bane, or trying to resurrect Tyranthraxus, or what. You'll recall that in the finale of Curse of the Azure Bonds, rakshasa occupying Myth Drannor had an uneasy alliance with Tyranthraxus and the party could even talk them out of it.
Thus begins our brief encounter with perhaps the best-fleshed-out NPC of the game.
Rakshasa are master illusionists and shape-shifters. They're always depicted as tiger-men in the Gold Box games, but I guess they can adopt a number of other anthropomorphic animal forms. Not only are they powerful spellcasters, but they're completely immune to spells themselves. [Edit: Apparently, they're only immune to spells through Level 8. I could have been "Meteor Swarm-ing" them or using "Power Word: Kill." I got through the end of the game before I discovered this, unfortunately.] This means that in combat with a pack of them, you have to try to hit them all with physical damage as quickly as possible, hoping to limit the number of them that can cast spells. They particularly like "Fireball" and "Lightning Bolt," so you want to immediately spread your party out--and get them away from walls. (Interestingly, their AI won't allow them to cast "Fireball" on top of themselves even though they're completely immune to it.)
And they like pipes and smoking jackets, apparently.
It was refreshing having a set of battles in which I didn't immediately go to "Delayed Blast Fireball." Another challenge was that many of the battles started with the rakshasa quite far away--beyond the range that I could charge in one round--so I found myself using missile weapons more often than any previous part of the game. Early in the map, I was given a crossbow and several "Blessed Bolts," which for some reason kill rakshasa immediately. These were naturally useful but there weren't many of them.

The map also had a host of basilisks, medusas, and dracolisks (encountered for the first time), so there were plenty of opportunities for more conventional "wipe-them-out-before-they-can-act" spells. Most of my party members had silver shields from the previous games, making them immune to the stoning gazes of these creatures.

Several screens showed rakshasa up to their old tricks, posing as elves or knights, but this time the game let me use "Detect Magic" to see through their illusions. (In Curse, I had to just guess.) It was one of them, captured, who told me that the rakshasa maharajah discovered how to "transfer life essence from one body to the next" and used the ability to re-animate Tyranthraxus with the souls of dead knights. Or something. This part wasn't very well-outlined.
I'm too experienced with Myth Drannor to fall for this.
As we proceeded through the ruins and found more dead knights, and even a rakshasa in the process of stealing the life force from one, Nacacia started to suffer a bit of a breakdown. Ultimately, over the bodies of several of them, she suffered a complete catatonia and wouldn't get up. I had options to "leave her," "comfort her," and "stand her up." The last option worked, and Nacacia re-joined the party with steely resolve. I'm not saying it's a huge amount of character development, but we're starting to see here some of the complex NPC characterization and role-playing options that would reach their zenith in the Bioware games in a few years.
Nacacia suffers a heroic B.S.O.D.
The map culminated in a temple where the rakshasa were finishing a ritual to resurrect Tyranthraxus. I expected to have to fight Big T again, but I was happy to find that I was able to interrupt the ritual with a "Dispel Evil" spell (glad I had one memorized). "The form of Tyranthraxus falls to the ground and disintegrates." There was a subsequent battle with 15 rakshasa, but my hastened characters wiped them out before they could get much spellcasting done.
According to GameBanshee, all of these options result in the interruption of the ritual and Tyranthraxus's immediate death, though you get more experience points for the first two.
I just love how this transpired. Tyranthraxus came back to consciousness just in time to see my party--who had already defeated him twice before--standing in front of him. Then he was destroyed before he could even speak. I like to think that my characters, after this game, will find a way to resurrect Tyranthraxus themselves, oh, once a year or so. They'll invite all their NPC friends from the Moonsea to a big annual party at Myth Drannor, cast the spell long enough to see his face again, laugh at him, and then return him to oblivion. Good times.
Granted, we don't have much material to work with.
Before we get to the next area, we have to review what we know about the dead god Moander, whose cultists appeared prominently in Curse of the Azure Bonds. In summary, Moander was the god of corruption and rot. Some elves found a way to seal him away from the material plane centuries ago, and since then, his fanatics have been trying to bring him back. One of these (failed) plots is recounted in the Azure Bonds book series.

In Curse, my party foiled a plot to return Moander to the material plane, and it resulted in Moander's death. Now, I guess, his body is just floating in a void somewhere, and his cultists are able to tap into his dead divinity to do things like animate bits of his flesh and trees.
A typical battle in a Moander-inspired dungeon.
Continuing my explorations, this time heading east along the bottom of the Moonsea, I next ran into a red tower. The tower turned out to be ruled by Marcus, the Black Circle mage from Secret of the Silver Blades, who in turn was in service to Tanetal, one of Bane's lieutenants. As I entered--after fighting a bunch of "Bits o Moander" and walking trees--I was greeted by Marcus's aide, Petra, who wasn't happy to see me.
The party is menaced by Anne of Green Gables.
The tower turned out to be 11 levels up and one down. In the basement was a locked door, from behind which a voice claimed, "beyond this gate is the city of Phlan, entombed here by some mighty spell, and besieged by monsters that sally through this very gate." The voice urged me to find and free Shal, a "high mage captured from among us."
I soon found Shal and freed her from some mage and priest captors. She looked suspiciously like Petra, and she was just a fighter, not a mage. Her story indicated that she was an expert on the Cult of Moander, so the Black Circle tried to coerce her into helping them use the dead god's powers. When she refused, she said, "they, ah, robbed me of my magic and imprisoned me here." The "ah" was her way to eliding that they, in fact, split her into two separate beings, one fighter, one mage, and the mage side became Marcus's aide Petra.

Up we went through the tower, fighting battles with cultists and mages all the way. They were relatively easy, having no immunity to spells. At one point, we encountered some Drow who were keen to take revenge against Marcus for destroying one of their cities when he re-located Phlan. (As commenter Null Null recently pointed out, the armies of Bane sure do a lot of their own in-fighting. There were a couple of other encounters where I was able to pit Marcus's mages and clerics against each other.) They wanted information about Petra, but I declined to tell them about Shal. Apparently, if I had, I would have had to fight them.
I took this shot somewhere in the tower. I no longer remember what it was referring to, but it sounds like something you'd get at Dairy Queen.
The levels were small and not worth mapping. At the top we found the Temple of Transformation, where pieces of Moander's flesh were cut away from his body and given life.
Marcus, looking a little like Denethor.
A final battle with Marcus introduced a new enemy called Minions of Bane. They come in two colors. Red ones went down so fast in melee combat I wasn't able to figure out what powers they had. Blue ones are surrounded by a lightning field that does damage to melee characters, plus they can breathe lightning. But the battle still wasn't very hard, and I soon killed Marcus despite him having buffed with "Mirror Image" before the battle.
One of three clusters of enemies in the final battle. Marcus stands to the northwest of the minion.
Petra and Shal re-united into a single being, I guess maintaining Shal's personality since her name was preserved in the final NPC.

Hovering above the tower had been some kind of "vessel" containing Moander's ichor and flesh, drawn through one of the Pools of Darkness. Now, for some reason, the giant cup started slamming against the tower and caused it to collapse. We had to jump from the tower to the disgusting cup to survive.
This part wasn't well-explained.
While we waited for the ichor to subside so we could access the Pool, Shal told us that Bane's lieutenant Tanetal, a powerful Glabrezu demon, could be found on Moander's dead body. Through the Pool we went, where Elminster seemed to know Shal. I guess she's a character in some of the Forgotten Realms books. She departed after telling me to "look her up" in Phlan and gave me a sword that turned out to be a vorpal blade, which sounds really cool but I forget what properties they're supposed to have.
Elminster is apparently Scottish.
Before continuing on to Moander's plane, I had Elminster return us to the Realms so I could finish investigating this silliness about Phlan. Elminster had a rope lowered from the portal to the ground, to take the place of the ruined tower. Soon, warriors from Phlan appeared and invited me inside. Almost immediately, we were attacked by a huge group of white dragons and black mages.

This frankly might have been the most difficult battle of the game so far. It took me 5 reloads to get through it with no deaths. The key problem was that there was no way to buff ahead of time. In a dungeon, you can buff one step before the battle, and because each step only takes one minute, the spells are still active when you arrive in the battle square. But in the wilderness, steps take 12 hours, so if you have an encounter that starts immediately when you arrive in a square (as here), all your spells are long expired by the time you reach it.
The white dragons were nothing; the problem was the 15 or so black mages, who started scattered in three clusters. Each one used "Lightning Bolt" as his go-to spell, and I had to get really lucky with some initiative rolls to ensure that my "Fireballs" hit the three groups before I got blasted with multiple bolts from multiple directions. Such bolts had a way of banking off walls and killing some of my lower-HP characters in a single round.
A very hard battle despite the existence of all this "Phlanarian" cannon fodder.
After I finally won that battle, things got pretty stupid. Phlan really had been lifted up wholesale and shoved underground beneath Marcus's tower. Its two maps were exactly the same as the two starting maps, with stores and temples all in the same places, and open for business. There was one extra encounter with some black mages holding a family hostage in a house, but otherwise the maps were indistinguishable from the opening areas of the game, including blue skies and clouds up above despite what was supposed to have happened to the city. How Marcus accomplished all of this is unexplained; I guess maybe there's a Level 10 spell called "Teleport Town" that I haven't received yet.
The docks area was a little different.
I figured there might be some quests associated with the city, but when I got to Town Hall, all Shal had to say was that Sasha had been kidnapped and "turned over to darkness itself" by someone named Gragnak Ulfim. She had no idea where to find her.
It would be fun if, at the end of all of this, Sasha turned out to be some kind of demi-god.
I returned to Limbo, stashed my equipment, and moved on to Moander's realm. This is perhaps the most unique "overland" map we've seen in an RPG so far. There are multiple openings in the corpse that lead to caves and whatnot, although the developers artfully positioned the body so as to avoid the party having to enter some truly unpleasant areas.
I had a visceral reaction when I saw it. I haven't been mentioning it all along, but I did play this game before, back in the late 1990s. Other than the game starting in Phlan, I didn't really remember anything about it, including whether I'd finished it. But I know I got at least this far, because the sight of Moander's corpse triggered some unpleasant memories. Specially, I remember spending forever on this damned map and hating every second of it. Next time, we'll see how well that memory holds up.

Miscellaneous notes:

  • When you successfully flee enemies in the wilderness, the ranger gets 500 individual experience points just for "leading the party past" the creatures.
  • As I explored Myth Drannor, the game kept telling me that rocks were falling in narrow corridors. Oddly, only Nacacia ever got hit with them. Was it because she was in the last place? 
  • Although you spend 99% of the game looting ruins with no penalty, I've learned from experience that the titles treat slain Myth Drannor figures with a certain reverence, and looting their bodies is "bad." Thus, I declined in this instance to take items from the skeleton of an elf. I got experience for declining. Later, I checked out a spoiler site to see what would have happened if I'd taken the items. The answer is that I would have gotten another Girdle of Giant Strength. Damn it.
Most of the time, you just find stuff and automatically go to the loot screen. When the game specifically asks if you want to take something, you know it's a trap.
  • "Haste" makes such a difference in combats that I've been using it more and more liberally, returning to Zhentil Keep to buy copious Elixirs of Youth every time my characters get over 35. Even though the elixirs cost 4,000 gold pieces each, I still have thousands of gems and pieces of jewelry.
  • Having a Ring of Blinking equipped turns out to be a double-edged sword. My healers can't target the character for "Dispel Magic" or "Heal," either.
  • You occasionally encounter random caravans selling goods in the wilderness. Here's what one of them had for sale. Really, what's the point?
The next time I complain about the economy, remind me of the "money sink" that is these boots and belts.

Time so far: 33 hours
Reload count: 35


  1. I think Rakshasa might be vulnerable to level 8 and 9 spells. I think the high-level ones are only vulnerable to level 9 spells?

    1. Haha, get this first line from the 1st ed Monster Manual:

      "Known first in India, these evil spirits encased in flesh are spreading"

      Do we suppose India to Myth Drannor is a one way trip?

      Coincidentally, I saw a lot art featuring Rakshasa when I was there a couple months ago. No portals to the Dalelands though.

    2. Wow. Yes, you're right. "Meteor Swarm" would have taken care of them. That would have really helped in one of the near-end battles.

  2. "a vorpal blade, which sounds really cool but I forget what properties they're supposed to have."

    A chance to behead the target, killing them instantly. And it survives the trip between realms as well, even though it's a +3 magical blade.

    "As I explored Myth Drannor, the game kept telling me that rocks were falling in narrow corridors. Oddly, only Nacacia ever got hit with them. Was it because she was in the last place?"

    Maybe she was the only one without 18 dexterity?

    "You occasionally encounter random caravans selling goods in the wilderness. Here's what one of them had for sale. Really, what's the point?"

    Selling mirrors to people who don't have silver shields?

    1. Maybe helms protect against damage? Or maybe it's checked vs AC?

    2. Another property of the vorpal blade: it goes 'snicker-snack!'

    3. Apparently, even if you hit someone in the leg with it, that person's head will roll off by itself!

  3. This game has been absolutely lousy with callbacks, so far you've seen Rolf, Sasha, Vala, Priam, Silk, Nacacia, Marcus, Tyranthraxus and Moander, also Fire Knives, Black Cricle mages, Red wizards and Zhents have shown up as enemies. But the entry of Shal is where thing get meta. Shal is the protagonist of the Pool of Radiance novelization. No idea where the petra sub-plot comes from, but guess it's possible there was another book(s) with her.

    1. Oh I knew the name was familiar.. Thanks! Great novels all of them

  4. Hmm, are the hands wrong on that picture of the Rakshasa in the smoking jacket? I thought one of the features of Rakshasas was that their hands are reversed. Or was that something that got added in a later edition?

    1. If you meant the Rakshasa in Indian folklore, then no.
      Maybe you were thinking of Yakshas or Asuras?

    2. As far as I can tell, the backwards hands are added in second edition (and continue to be a signature feature of d&d rakshasas to this day, of course). The AD&D 1e Monster Manual doesn't mention the hands (and, in fact, includes a black and white version of the same image as shown in Pools of Darkness, complete with pipe and "smoking jacket", and includes the line crpgaddict quoted, "Known first in India, these evil spirits encased in flesh are spreading.") The 2e Monstrous Manual states that "hands whose palms curve backwards, away from the body, seem to be common".

  5. Shouldn't it be "phlanarian war is terrifying"? My problem with this name is that it is too close to "planaria", and "planarian war" isn't that terrifying

    1. It should be "Phlanarian Warrior" but it's cut off.

  6. Shal was my favorite NPC from the game. The backstory was interesting and I liked that she would warn the party of the different types of Bits o Moandar in the tower.

    In the Moandar plane, if you cast summon monster, you get two Bits o Moandar. I liked that; better than spiders!.

    1. I wonder if summoning area-appropriate monsters is supposed to be a "feature" of the spell or if it's just a limitation of the programming.

    2. I think it might be a case of limitation and effect happily coexisting (probably unintentionally).

      Monster summoning is intended to give results reflective of the terrain, so if someone had spent time and effort coding a bunch of different possibilities depending on location, you would end up summoning inter-dimensional weirdness in that zone.

      But I think the somewhat accurate result was an accident of memory restrictions in all likelihood.

    3. Probably an accident of memory restrictions originally, but depending on implementation, it may have required conscious effort to keep it that way for this title.

      As people commented in prior entries for this title, it's the first gold box game to require disk and thus have enough memory to allow for the full roster of monster types in each area (thus the emissaries/incursions from other lieutenants in each area with different types).

      A naive implementation of monster summoning that just relied on summoning from the monsters loaded in memory would likely have resulted in weird behavior here. I can imagine that being something found during playtesting.

  7. I laughed out loud a couple of times at your captions and almost woke my wife.

    It seems like you are engaged and having fun again, and I think it reflects in your writing.

    Thanks fir the post!

    1. I'm glad to hear that. Thanks for the feedback.

    2. This was especially gold: "They'll invite all their NPC friends from the Moonsea to a big annual party at Myth Drannor, cast the spell long enough to see his face again, laugh at him, and then return him to oblivion. Good times."

  8. According to GameBanshee, all of these options result in the interruption of the ritual and Tyranthraxus's immediate death

    Even "Flee"?

    1. "No matter what you do, you'll disrupt the ritual and you'll start a battle." I didn't have a chance to check it out personally, though.

  9. The setup of Phlan is strange. On the one hand it serves as a good base of operations -- it has places to rest, train, buy/sell/appraise items, and convenient access to Elminster's vault. It also has a council clerk to send you on quests.

    BUT, then they go and position Phlan extremely far from where you start so you're unlikely to discover it until you've already completed all the quests that the clerk might send you on, plus you have to beat that super-tough white dragon/black mage fight to get to it. So it doesn't make much sense to go there until you've improved your characters quite a bit. But you presumably miss out on having the clerk send you on quests.

    Mulmaster has a very similar issue.

    1. Oh, wow. The clerk actually does send you on quests? I just figured they had a couple of dialogue bits about that for old times' sake. What kind of quests? All those miscellaneous farms and whatnot?

    2. I don't recall specifically. But they are more likely the optional quests like the Temple of Tyr, Taydome's Keep, and Myth Drannor than the farmhouse-type quests.

      In any event, the official cluebook does say that the clerk sends you on missions, so I don't think I'm making this up.

    3. I looked it up (someone printed out all the game text). You get sent to help Priam, Vala, Nacacia, and Sasha, as you guessed.

      So you can get the minor quests from the council or, ironically, the bad guys in Mulmaster (who will also send you after some people you've already beaten).

    4. So that's interesting. When I ran into Arcam, it seemed like he was going to give me some kind of quest, but then he suddenly said something like, "You're too powerful. Your task is to die!" So I assume if I hadn't completed everything up to this point, he would have tasked me with killing the other lieutenants?

  10. He took his vorpal sword in hand:
    Long time the manxome foe he sought --
    So rested he by the Tumtum tree,
    And stood a while in thought.

    And, as in uffish thought he stood,
    The Jabberwock, with eyes of flame,
    Came whiffling through the tulgey wood,
    And burbled as it came!

    One two! One two! And through and through
    The vorpal blade went snicker-snack!
    He left it dead, and with its head
    He went galumphing back

    Nethack's Vorpal Blade (not sure which version introduced it) had a 1 in 20 chance of outright killing any monster by beheading. Boy, does it suck when some Mordor orc picks it up and beheads YOU. You're doing fine in your game, and then out of nowhere you see: "Vorpal Blade decapitates you!" --MORE-- You die... --MORE-- Do you want your possessions identified? (y/n)

    Huh, so the aging mechanic does work in Goldbox games, then? You start losing stats and then you die in your sleep? How's it work, exactly? I thought there wasn't even any code in the game to implement the ill effects of aging by haste.

    1. AD&D'a Vorpal Blade is the same thing, essentially: a nat-20 on the attack beheads whatever you are attacking (which kills it if it is something that beheading would kill.)

      There were also Swords of Sharpness that de-limbed on a natural 20; I don't think those were implemented in any Gold Box games.

    2. In FRUA, it crashes your computer.

      You could always Camp, rest and cast Haste, and see what happens. Given how many 3rd-level spells you can memorize in POD it's a pretty good opportunity.

    3. Back in CotAB, I did take the time to cast "Haste" a few hundred times. My human characters got above 200 for their ages but never had any problems. I don't know if they finally implemented something here, but I figured I'd keep everyone young just in case.

    4. If a character is over the max age for their race, they have a chance after every combat to die. (I had this happen due to some hex-editing mishaps: changed race from Elf to Human, but forgot to change age from 134 or whatever—young for an Elf—to 20something.)

    5. I remember playing in a campaign where one of my Ranger's dual magic blades was a Sword of Truth.

      On one occasion when I rolled a natural 20 to hit a half-orc gladiator, he (the DM) screamed, "I peeped on my aunt while she was bathing when I was 10 and I liked it!"

  11. 'I guess maybe there's a Level 10 spell called "Teleport Town" that I haven't received yet.'

    It's not called exactly that, but you can find a number of oddly specific, high-level spells sprinkled through various AD&D material.

  12. It was a beneficial choice not looting the elf in Myth Drannor. The hardest battles are in other dimensions and the girdle of giant strength doesn't survive inter-dimensional travel but the bonus XP you got instead did.


I welcome all comments about the material in this blog, and I generally do not censor them. However, please follow these rules:

1. Do not link to any commercial entities, including Kickstarter campaigns, unless they're directly relevant to the material in the associated blog posting. (For instance, that GOG is selling the particular game I'm playing is relevant; that Steam is having a sale this week on other games is not.) This also includes user names that link to advertising.

2. Please avoid profanity and vulgar language. I don't want my blog flagged by too many filters. I will delete comments containing profanity on a case-by-case basis.

3. NO ANONYMOUS COMMENTS. It makes it impossible to tell who's who in a thread. If you don't want to log in to Google to comment, either a) choose the "Name/URL" option, pick a name for yourself, and just leave the URL blank, or b) sign your anonymous comment with a preferred user name in the text of the comment itself.

4. I appreciate if you use ROT13 for explicit spoilers for the current game and upcoming games. Please at least mention "ROT13" in the comment so we don't get a lot of replies saying "what is that gibberish?"

5. Comments on my blog are not a place for slurs against any race, sex, sexual orientation, nationality, religion, or mental or physical disability. I will delete these on a case-by-case basis depending on my interpretation of what constitutes a "slur."

Blogger has a way of "eating" comments, so I highly recommend that you copy your words to the clipboard before submitting, just in case.

I read all comments, no matter how old the entry. So do many of my subscribers. Reader comments on "old" games continue to supplement our understanding of them. As such, all comment threads on this blog are live and active unless I specifically turn them off. There is no such thing as "necro-posting" on this blog, and thus no need to use that term.

I will delete any comments that simply point out typos. If you want to use the commenting system to alert me to them, great, I appreciate it, but there's no reason to leave such comments preserved for posterity.

I'm sorry for any difficulty commenting. I turn moderation on and off and "word verification" on and off frequently depending on the volume of spam I'm receiving. I only use either when spam gets out of control, so I appreciate your patience with both moderation tools.