Pagan: Ultima VIII
United States
ORIGIN Systems (developer); Electronic Arts (publisher)
Released 1994 for DOS, 1995 for PC-98
Date Started: 24 July 2026
Released 1994 for DOS, 1995 for PC-98
Date Started: 24 July 2026
Date Ended: 9 November 2026
Total Hours: 51
Difficulty: Moderate (3.0/5)
Final Rating: (to come later)
Ranking at Time of Posting: (to come later)
Summary:
The Ultima series is greatly reduced in this sequel, as the Avatar explores the world of Pagan in an isometric view with no fellow party members, limited character development, and action-based combat. Traditional RPG elements are eclipsed by climbing and jumping puzzles and four completely different magic systems, none of which are terribly necessary to conquer the game's foes, most of which can simply be ignored. Graphics and sound are good enough for the era, but the all-mouse movement system is a glitchy nightmare.
As usual, Origin deserves some credit for giving us a more complicated story than most RPGs of the era, starting with a well-written Chronicle of Pagan, extensive NPC dialogue, and in-game books. Also as usual, Origin deserves plenty of criticism for a plot that doesn't make a lot of sense and an ending that raises more questions than it answers. In the end, it's a surprisingly unnecessary game; if the Guardian's hand had plucked the Avatar from the end of Ultima VII: Part Two and deposited him directly into Ultima IX, we would have lost nothing.
****
I begin my postgame analysis by checking out things that I missed or could have done differently. According to the official cluebook (Pentology, credited to Melissa Mead) as well as various walkthroughs, wikis, and online maps:
- Although I thought I reviewed the game materials carefully, I completely missed that it came with a map of the island. The map would not have helped much with navigation, but it would have cleared up the relationship between the various areas and the reason that high cliffs surround every map. It is completely upside-down, though.
- I missed a magic axe called Deceiver, mentioned in the book Dispelling Myths: The Truth About Magic. I failed to notice that there were small islands off the coast of Stone Cove which the Avatar could hop around, finding Deceiver on one of them.
- Obviously, I could have favored Vardion instead of Bane in the Daemon's Crag quests, but it sounds like they had essentially identical dialogue.
- I could have used the Breath of Wind on Stratos while still on the islands north of Daemon's Crag, bypassing her entire realm later on. Apparently, in the original (unpatched) game, this caused some problems, as air magic became unusable once the Breath of Wind was taken.
- It was not necessary to walk across the great Pentagram on Daemon's Crag and free Pyros. I could have saved myself some fire and brimstone, but this otherwise had no long-term effect.
- The final area is called the Ethereal Plane by the cluebook and each of the sub-areas is the Plane of Whatever Element. I feel like maybe the game was cribbing from Might and Magic here. So to the various named elemental lords.
- In the Plane of Fire, I was supposed to collect a bunch of little spheres and use them on the star puzzle to create a platform. I'm not sure why this would ever have been necessary, even in the unpatched version.
- Casting "Create Golem" to open the doors leading into the Heart of Earth is actually a workaround. It's supposedly possible to recover the key to these doors from another place in the Pit of Death.
- I missed the whole "ghost subplot" involving the cave with the locked doors in the Valley. Commenters hinted at this but I didn't really care. I would have had to talk to a number of NPCs in a specific order about stories of a ghost haunting the area. Kilandra would have directed me to her daughter's crave, where a ghost would have thrown down a key. Back in the cave, the key would have opened the locked door and led me to the "ghost," a floating suit of armor that I would have needed "Aerial Servant" to retrieve. It would have been the same type of magic armor found in a couple other locations.
- I could have used the Skull of Quakes to open the way to another teleport pad in the dungeon. I guess it would have helped a few times, but it was soon obviated by pads discovered in other locations.
- Flame Sting, which I picked up but never used, is a reasonably cool weapon that causes flame to gout from the ground underneath the enemies that the Avatar strikes.
- As commenters noted, Pagan's version of "Armageddon" is called "Devastation." Mythran happily sells it for 1,000 gold pieces. When cast, it kills everyone, including the Avatar. "Rock Flesh" protects from it, but the Avatar ends up rooted in place, unable to move. The Avatar cannot move after it's cast, so you can't cast it just before walking into the obelisk.
- Not only did I never find a use for "Withstand Death" (although it also works against "Devastation"), it turns out to be a lie that it can only be cast once.
- Once the player wins the game, a "quotes" link shows up in the main menu. If you click on it, you can read a bunch of whimsical, out-of-context quotes while circus music plays in the background. The whole thing strikes me as enormously cringey, like the gag reel from a sitcom that flopped. Inside jokes are only funny on the inside.
![]() |
| Once again, I'm not sure Richard Garriott's employees liked him that much. Another quote is attributed to "incomprehensible Richard gibberish." |
One thing I did not miss is how to open the doors in the cave north of the Plateau. These double doors, around which a couple dozen skeletons lie scattered, were supposed to lead into the Lost Vale, the game's planned expansion. Although the programming for this expansion is said to be lost, Origin programmer Bill Randolph supplied design documents to fan sites in 2011.
The documents give several outlines of the expansion, each with slightly different details. The one that seems to be the most "final" begins with a vision from Lord British, who says that Nystul has managed to "break through the Guardian's veil of magic," confirming the Guardian's claims that he is currently attacking Britannia while the Avatar is in Pagan. Lord British tells the Avatar that some Zealans are still alive and that Mythran has more information. Mythran says that a man named Galjeron was searching for the Zealans and went to the other side of those double doors. In my favorite part of the design document, we learn that "the Avatar must solve some damn puzzle to get the key."
Galjeron is found dead on the other side of the doors, his journal directing the Avatar to a dungeon where he must find "four magic coupons" aspected to the four elements. These are found in four parts of the dungeon, each with a different elemental theme. The coupons let the Avatar pass four barriers into the Lost Vale.
The Zealans in the Lost Vale are at war, with one sect wanting to remain hidden and the other wanting to join the Pagans. Both sects are running out of food and water. The Avatar rescues a high priestess named Ezrekal, outcast because she can no longer communicate with the Zealan gods. The gods have been sealed in the Shrine of the Wheaties after the titans attacked them some centuries prior. (I assume "Shrine of the Wheaties" was a placeholder. There are several of these, including a "Test of Rutabaga.") The Avatar has to scale some cliffs to visit the gods' old palace on the top of a mountain. The documents start to break down a bit here, but in the end:
The Avatar must reunite the two feuding tribes in order to free the gods from their entrapment. There is a young couple, one from each side of the feud, who are in love. The Avatar uses them to reunite the two factions in the shrine and use the people's combined strength (faith?) to free the gods.
The barren vale is rendered lush again, and the Avatar gets a Bag of Reagents that I assume is like the Ring of Reagents in The Silver Seed expansion to Ultima VII: Part Two. I can't think of a more worthless prize. One document says he'd also be given a shield that by itself maxes the Avatar's armor class, allowing him to discard the other pieces of armor and alleviate encumbrance. Beyond that, there's a suggestion that the Avatar would get some "wisdom" from the Zealans, perhaps justifying why Lord British insisted he visit them in the first place.
The document that I describe as "most complete" has some fun designers' notes. I quote a few here, along with some other comments.
- "The PC encounters a new monster, the harpie [sic]. This is another familiar old Britannia monster. Couldn't we come up with a cool new Pagan monster?" There's a lot of discussion in the notes about how the expansion will be efficient because it will re-use assets from the main game. This must have been a controversial suggestion.
- "The gods further explain to the PC that if he defeats all four Titans, he may be able to achieve such a position himself . . . U8 overall would be aided by something of an explanation here concerning the weird endgame, which many customers have expressed puzzlement over. The gods might also offer some insight into what is happening in Britannia." That certainly would have been welcome, as I ended Pagan with a lot of questions.
- "We strongly recommend that the player be allowed to travel back [and] forth from Pagan to the Lost Vale. This will cause the player to perceive 'The Lost Vale' as a longer, less linear add-in." I don't know about this. The plot of Pagan is so linear that it's hard to imagine flitting in and out of The Lost Vale between its stages.
- The notes suggest two additions that made it into the patch: the Bonecrusher hammer, found in the caverns leading to the vale, and changing the plaque on "the Birthplace of Moriens" to say exactly that. "This would not be a difficult thing to do, and it would please a great number of customers."
- A dialogue document suggests the Zealans would have talked like Yoda, with phrases like, "Funny, not like a Zealan you look" and "Answer [Ezrekal] the Ancients would not; accused her of lying the people did."
- Other than a potential harpy, the only new monster mentioned in the documents is a "water zombie."
- The one thing that the expansion could have done to redeem the main game a bit is to feature puzzles that require all the different magic systems to solve.
The documents say that the expansion would be ready by August 1994, but development must have lingered beyond that, as EA announced its cancellation in September. By then, the company had created at least one prototype box which made its way to eBay in 2005, selling for $1,923. A couple of years ago, a disk with some of the game's usecode surfaced, largely confirming the plot described above.
To me, the proposed plot to The Lost Vale is so boilerplate 1990s Origin that it's almost a parody. The company just loves chapters in which the Avatar is on a mostly-linear plot, progress gated by NPC dialogue, in which gameplay occasionally flares outward into four areas that must be individually conquered before everything comes back together for a tidy ending. As usual, character development, inventory, and combat mechanics are all afterthoughts. I don't think I would have enjoyed it. I think I would have berated it for adding nonsense to an already-long game. That's kind of how I felt about The Silver Seed.
My entries on Pagan have been generally negative. I found it a disappointing game. Traditional character development has never been a strength of the series, but here it's reduced to three statistics that are maxed during the first quarter of the game. That's fine, because enemies (with the sole exception of Khumash-Gor) are annoyances to be brushed aside rather than obstacles to be overcome. The magic systems are intriguing but logistically annoying and so under-used as to be laughable.
That leaves the story. The early Ultima games told tight stories in which everything had a purpose and explanation. (They sometimes didn't make sense in sequence, but at least they were internally consistent.) Sometimes they were a little too tidy, and I really don't mind when games go the other way, telling stories of great complexity and moral ambiguity, in which mysteries are unresolved and players have to pay careful attention to understand histories, motivations, and consequences. I don't mind when games leave thick loam for fan theories to take root. At least, I don't mind when that type of storytelling is deliberate. Pagan doesn't make me feel that the developers were going for that kind of deliberate complexity. It just feels sloppy.
The part I hated most about Pagan is the Avatar himself. When I played Ultima IV as a teenager, I was enchanted with the idea that the Avatar was literally my Avatar, warped into Britannia through the Moongate of the computer screen. The materials reinforced this interpretation. Ultima V maintained that illusion, but Ultima VI began taking it apart. Not "deconstructing" it, which would have been clever, but simply dismantling it, transitioning the Avatar to a generic RPG hero. Even as it did this, however, it at least maintained some fidelity to the virtues introduced in Ultima IV. When it challenged those virtues, there was at least a little cleverness in the challenge. Ultima VI introduced the idea that another society could start with three different, but still reasonable, principles of virtue and end up with an entirely different ethical system. Ultima VII: The Black Gate (still one of the best setups in RPG history) showed how noble-sounding ethical rules could be twisted to evil ends.
I've read sites that try to see the same complexity in Pagan. I quote here from Jimmy Maher's excellent blog article on the subject:
Here you are, the Avatar, on an alien world where abiding by the virtues will not help you. You have to lie, cheat, steal, and yes, kill innocent children (optional) to progress ahead. It’s nothing you haven’t done before (the first three Ultimas were all about laying waste to whole towns to advance in level), but it is a very morose take on the Avatar in the Age of Virtue.
He goes on to catalogue some of the worst offenses committed by the Avatar on Pagan, including lying his way to the top of each magic order, freeing two of the elemental titans, stealing the Breath of Wind (which apparently killed Stellos!? I didn't see that), participating in ritual sacrifice, and in general leaving Pagan in worse shape than when he arrived.
The problem with this approach is that it's not at all clear to me that it's what the authors intended. Sure, the Guardian says, "No one here knows of the Avatar" as he dumps the PC in the sea. But Pagan, while not a nice place, is also not an amoral hellscape. The few remaining people seem to have the same sorts of ethics as the rest of the universe. They hate the tyrant Mordea. They mourn their lost family members. They love their children. They mostly recognize that the titans are monstrous and therefore have found ways to limit their power. They praise courage in battle and fidelity to duty. In an early entry, I criticized the episode in which a bunch of little girls attack the Avatar and he's forced to kill them to defend himself. I now think the opposite: if the game really wanted to be about brutal consequentialism in a ruined society (something Fallout likes to toy with), then everyone should have attacked the Avatar when he arrived. The people should have adored Mordea. Their books should be warped and disturbing. Rhian should have betrayed Toran to Mordea's goons instead of weeping for him. Instead, these are normal people living under brutal circumstances, and what the Avatar does to them is unforgivable.
Even worse, it's not clear why he's doing it. I mean, I'm controlling the damned character, but I don't know why I'm doing half the stuff I'm doing. Some guy said I had to master all four types of magic to leave this place? Why? How? Do I even want to leave that badly? This is admittedly par for the course by 1994. Except in a few cases, we don't have voiced protagonists who make their thoughts and motivations known. All I can tell you is that they're no longer my motivations. I don't care so much about moving on to the next world that I'm willing to destroy a society to do so. I did it because the game forced me to. It doesn't help that the Avatar is this mute idiot hiding behind a helm (even when he's not wearing a helm), prompting NPCs with dialogue but never making his own choices or hinting at his own feelings. I feel like Ultima VII, for all the limited roleplaying it offered, would have at least allowed the Avatar to say, "You want me to do @#*@#*$ what?!" when confronted with some of these plot points.
Among the many videos and articles I consulted for this entry is a massive 3.5-hour retrospective by YouTuber Majuular. He's done long videos on the entire Ultima series. I want to quote a long passage from near the end of the video, as it summarizes how I feel perfectly.
Here we are in Pagan, tearing souls from the void and getting undead to fight for us, stealing lifesaving magic from innocent people, summoning a demon to help fight the other demon we accidentally summoned, trying to undergo apotheosis to become a god to the people of Pagan . . . and for what? To go home? To become powerful enough to stave off the Guardian for another game? Says who? And at what cost? Like, what are we doing here? . . . I think Ultima VIII's corruption of the Avatar and its repudiation of the virtues doesn't work because it sucks. Pagan fails to deconstruct the series' foundation because it's not really clever enough to replace those missing Jenga tiles. It undermines itself without offering an alternative perspective or even asking interesting questions. It looks you in the eyes, asks, "What if Avatar bad?!," smirks like it just said something intelligent, and then cannonballs into a bottomless pit before you have a chance to ask it any clarifying questions.
The story told by Garriott over the years is that Origin's purchase by Electronic Arts, a publicly-traded company, created greater pressure to serve quarterly earnings, leading to rushed development, overworked staff, and cut content. It's hard not to be sympathetic. Ultima VII, Part Two (which, despite its name, is a full standalone game) came out in March 1993, Pagan only a year later. Apparently, EA was pushing for a Christmas 1993 release, which would have been insane by any standard.
I'm not sure more time could have saved Pagan. I think it was flawed from the beginning. Did any Ultima fan really want a mainline game set in some weird world in which the only goal is to get back to the places the Avatar actually cares about? Did any RPG player of the period really want platforming puzzles? If content had to be cut, why wouldn't they have started with the overly complex magic systems? Why did they waste time on a story that contradicts everything we were told about Pagan in the previous games? If I had been asked to make Pagan on a tight deadline and a shoestring budget, I would have set it on the Guardian's homeworld like originally planned. You could keep most of the backstory. The population has been reduced to feral, scavenging, sniveling wretches by a group of amoral titans. There are no cities and significantly limited dialogue. The Avatar has to try to feel some sympathy for these people he's trying to help even though they do nothing but hinder him. Open exploration, emphasizing proper character development, inventory, and a new magic system we've never seen before allows him to find the clues and items he needs to defeat the titans.
Let's move on to the GIMLET. I hated the way I did the Ravenloft rating, so I guess we're going back to simple bulleted paragraphs.
- 5 points for the game world. Flawed, it still gives me most of what I'm looking for, including a detailed backstory and plenty of lore. You can't say that the Avatar's actions don't measurably affect the game world.
- 1 point for character creation and development. Creation options (sex, portrait, class) have been entirely stripped away and development is limited to boosts in three statistics that start at 15 and max at 25. Maxing all those statistics is possible in less than 30 minutes and inevitable in less than a few hours. No, screw it, it doesn't even deserve 2. I'm going down to 1.
- 5 points for NPC interaction. Just like the first category, I don't like the results of much of the interaction, but most games of the era weren't given us any interaction at all. I don't feel that the Avatar's dialogue options are really "options," though.
- 3 points for encounters and foes. The monsters are pathetic. There are a few non-combat encounters and puzzles that I don't mind, but I'm definitely not giving any points for the jumping puzzles.
- 4 points for magic and combat. Almost all of that goes to magic. I agree that having four different systems (five, if you count the one you can't learn) is unique and fits with the lore. Interface and inventory problems belong in those categories. I just wish that the magic system had been used more: more NPCs who reacted to "Hear Truth," more puzzles that needed to be solved with spells. "Open Ground," "Aerial Servant," and "Create Golem" did recur in a few places. There is no need in the game to cast a single offensive spell except maybe "Grant Peace."
- 4 points for equipment. I could have used more of it (and a better combat system to go with it), but finding the magic weapons was fun, and I particularly like that their locations were tied to the game's lore via the books. The game has a few armor upgrades. Potions and scrolls are always useful.
- 2 points for economy. Unless you really want to destroy the world with "Devastation," there is virtually no need to collect all of those obsidian pieces.
- 3 points for quests. Main quest, a couple of side areas, a couple of minor options along the way. I originally gave it 4, but it loses a point for the main quest being so abstruse.
- 3 points for graphics, sound, and interface. Let me be clear about this. Even though I didn't like the graphics as much as everyone else, they're worth at least 2 points. Sound effects are worth at least 2 points. The reason that this category doesn't have at least 4 is because I hated the interface so much that it gets -1 instead of just 0. I hated several aspects of it: the all-mouse movement, the difficulty clicking or double-clicking on moving things, the difficulty facing the right way in combat, the absurdly crowded backpack, and of course the jumping puzzles, which would have been worth -3 in the original version. The game also really needed an automap.
- 2 points for gameplay. It's only a bit nonlinear, too long, and not replayable.
That gives us a final score of 32, which is the lowest rating I have given to an Ultima game except Ultima II. It's two points lower than the original Ultima. I want to emphasize that my ratings are absolute and not relative to the year of the game's release. This means that I consider the original Ultima from 1981, primitive as it was, to be Pagan's superior in quality. At least I could choose my class. And if the game had to do weird experimental stuff with the interface, I'd rather shoot tie fighters than leap across platforms.
I don't always agree with Scorpia, but like me she understood what made Ultima special better than its creator. So I was happy to see that in the July 1994 Computer Gaming World, she dislikes Pagan more than even me. "If you were expecting characterization, rich story, and role playing—you're expecting it from the wrong game," she says in the first paragraph. She has a few things to praise: lack of bugs, faster loading, an inventory that, while jumbled, at least doesn't reorganize itself every time you open the backpack. "After that, sad to say, it's all downhill." She hates the jumping puzzles and doesn't find value in the magic system: "Origin created a nightmare of multiple systems with differing requirements." She calls sorcery "an inane charade . . . whose tedium and frustration cannot be conveyed by mere words." But she saves her worst invective for the plot: "Pagan may not be a happy place, but at least the inhabitants have achieved stability and can survive. Along comes the Avatar and blows it all away, in a very un-Avatar fashion."
I was particularly happy to see her agree that the "robotic" appearance of the Avatar damages any sense of player identification: "There is nothing human about it. For the first time ever in any CRPG, I felt no identification whatsoever with the character. It was only a thing on the screen I maneuvered to get through the game, and nothing more." She wraps up with a discussion of the limited character development system and meaningless combat. "Overall, Pagan is a disaster, and an embarrassment to Origin, Lord British, and Ultima fans everywhere." In the November 1996 issue, CGW ranked the game as one of the 50 worst games of all time.
Scorpia's opinion (and mine) are far from universal. European magazines are far more charitable than American ones. MobyGames's review summary has ratings as high as 98% from the French Génération 4 and averaging in the high 80s. Many of these magazines seemed to prize the graphics and saw the simplification of role-playing mechanics as a welcome streamlining of gameplay. Wikipedia says that in 1997, PC Gamer UK ranked it among the best computer games of all time, ahead of every other Ultima. I haven't been able to find a copy of the issue.
What the reviewers of the time didn't know, but we of course do, is that players would have to wait five years for Ultima IX: Ascension (1999) and that game would hardly redeem the series. In between was Ultima Online (1997), which of course exemplified a very different sort of gameplay.
****
For further reading:
- My Index of Games Played by Lineage has the Ultima series and its clones.
- Digital Antiquarian Jimmy Maher's take on the game.
- An excellent retrospective by YouTuber Majuular.
11/17/2026






























